It started with this email:
- ----- Original Message -----
From: "matilda amanda" matilda.amanda@googlemail.com
To: "Sabine Hossenfelder" sabina@perimeterinstitute.ca
Sent: Thursday, May 14, 2009 4:42 PM
Subject: Re: SEK10000 Looking for Apt Sep 1st 2009 (Stockholm),Reply
Hi,thanks for your response to my advert.The apartment is a lovely one
for rent in Stockholm.The apartment has 2 nice rooms and kitchen,it
also has a living room and 2 bathrooms.The whole apartment is 10000SEK
with deposit of
8000SEK.It is in Gotgatan 130 Stockholm 118 26 Sweden.The apartment
has the following facilities:Wireless internet
facilities,Phone,Microwave,washing
machine,Dryer,Refrigerator,bathroom, toilet, lounge/living room,
kitchen, utility room, front and rear garden you rent it from me fully
furnished..I will be planning my wedding this summer so wont be back
to Stockholm about December so you can rent until then..
My number to call is +447031899713
To be honest, I hadn't spent any thought on potential rental fraud before I posted my ad. This email however seemed odd to me immediately because unlike what "she" wrote, I had not replied to her ad, but she to mine. However, I wrote back that I wouldn't be interested in a temporary place until December, and thus the offer wouldn't work for me. In reply I was then assured the apartment would be available for at least 18 months, no problem. I found this change weird, but asked to arrange for a date to visit, upon which "Matilda" said I would have to send money to make a "reservation". I replied
- "If you mean with 'reservation' I'm supposed to blindly send money to somebody who just happens to have sent me an email, you'll have to look for somebody more stupid. For all I know you might not even own the place. Best -Sabine"
And that was that. Not exactly the most polite thing to do, I know. I immediately felt bad about it. The next email was the following
----- Original Message -----
From: "Ronald Kegan" startkick1@ymail.com
To: "Sabine Hossenfelder" sabina@perimeterinstitute.ca
Sent: Thursday, May 14, 2009 5:34 PM
Subject: 1 bedroom apartment for rent in Stockholm
Hi,
I work as Volunteer with a Non Governmental Organization in West Africa,Nigeria.The apartment will cost 4000 SEK per month including utilities.A 55sqm apartment which has just been refurnished,and situated in a very safe area ideal for families.
The fully equipped, separated kitchen is brand-new and has all kinds of kitchen implements that you may need.The bathroom is fully equipped with a bath tub, shower, wash basin, bidet and toilet.For your safety the apartment is also equipped with a reinforced door and a safe box, where you can store all your valuables.
A perfect place to stay for anyone interested in good food, night life and sightseeing.The apartment also has WI-FI Internet service,telephone service, electric oven, microwave, washing machine, refrigerator and a spacious parking garage.
Regards,
Ronald.
Which I found also odd, though for other reaons. Why would I care whether that person is in Nigeria? Another "offer" for a two-bedroom apartment came from somebody who called himself "Tommy Heart" with an immediate request for a deposit. When I wrote back - politely and sanely as I thought - I of course wouldn't send money to anybody without having seen the place I got the following reply
- From: "heart tommy" toheart101@gmail.com
To: "Sabine Hossenfelder" sabina@perimeterinstitute.ca
Sent: Sunday, May 17, 2009 9:28 AM
Subject: Re: SEK10000 Looking for Apt Sep 1st 2009.. YOU GOT ONE ..
what i'm try to let you know is that many are interseted in the
apartment ok just for you make arrangement with my lawyer cos he will
meet you,meanwhile you can make aprovision of paying some amount of
money but you will just show me the reciept for ment then we will now
book a date for visit ok with out that you can get your own house
else wear ok bye
tommy
To which I replied with ok, bye. After all, if so many people are interested in the place, why did you bother writing to me to begin with? I got a couple of more emails of that sort which I will spare you, all in a very similar tone. Usually in a bad English, with tiny photos attached that I suspect are downloaded elsewhere, with an explanation of some sort for why one is not in town. It follows fast a request to send money, with some indication of having made bad experiences. There seems to be lot of people on some mission in Nigeria, or planning a wedding. For example this person
- ----- Original Message -----
From: "Leyla Pursharifi" leylanijo@googlemail.com
To: "Sabine Hossenfelder" sabina@perimeterinstitute.ca
Sent: Monday, May 18, 2009 6:59 AM
Subject: Pictures of Apartment in (Stockholm)
Dear Sabine,
Good Afternoon,thanks for the prompt in response.My apartment is Located
at [...]
The pictures are attached with this mail so that you can see if you
like it or not. We can also chat on MSN on minemine4youall@hotmail.com
If you are okay to proceed then do send me your details for the
contract ,the details are below.
Your name
Your address
Move in date and move out date
A scan copy of your ID
I am in Italy now Planning a wedding ceremony.
I am an easy going lady,i am 25 Years.i am Single.i like meeting
people,i like traveling.My profession is Wedding Planner under Event
Manager.
Feel free to ask me any question if you have got any.I like to know
more about you too.
I will send my picture in the next mail.Thanks i await for your response.
Best Regards,
Leyla
(I left out some irrelevant details.) I checked all the street addresses, they do exist. However, at this point I had gotten very suspicious of all these offers and I did a Google search for "Craigslist Rental Fraud" which turned up more than 200,000 results! Apparently rental fraud has taken off within the last year. There are lots of reports from people who got cheated on either when replying to a posted ad, or when getting offers after posting an ad. I read a lot of sad stories, many of which started with an email like the ones I received. Searching Wordpress for the tag Craiglist Scam also give you a sense of what's going on.
I deleted my ad from Craigslist to avoid getting more of these emails. After some searching, I found the following very useful websites that list a lot of examples, as well as names, email addresses and phone numbers that are being used for the scams. Most notably there is a blog called Here be Dragons. On this list for example there appears "Matilda's" phone number as well as the "easygoing wedding planner" in an email with exactly the same wording that I got, just that her name is "Angelique" instead of "Leyla" and the alleged apartment in Geneva instead of Stockholm. Another useful repository is a blog called Let's Get the Craigslist Scammers. The story with the mission worker in West Africa seems to be particularly common.
I also found out that a lot of the scams come from Nigeria. Thus, I checked on the IP address of the only offer left that didn't reproduce any of these known stories. A person claiming to be "Ruth Star" living in the UK who has to go and ask her dad for advice after every mail (since I annoyingly keep refusing to send money). In contrast to all the other emails, the English is okay in this case. Turns out however the sender's IP address is located in, guess what, Nigeria. Amazingly enough, she sent me a photo of a British passport (allegedly her dad's) which makes me wonder whose passport this might have been. The photo isn't particularly good though, it's hard to tell whether the name has been edited or not, but the background looks quite authentic.
Anyway, though luckily I didn't send money to any of these scammers and all I've lost is time, the sheer abundance in which these scams are apparently tried depressed me quite a lot. What makes people try to earn their living by ripping off others?
Meanwhile, I am still looking for an apartment in Stockholm. If you happen to know somebody who knows somebody who knows somebody... please send me a note.














As the DPG spring meetings are traditionally well attended by young students, dominantly those carrying a Y-chromosome, the lecture hall was completely crowded when 