Some days ago I received a Facebook message that asked me to confirm Moshe is “owner” of the blog Shores of the Dirac Sea. Which I did and while at it, I too joined that Facebook blog network, upon which I had to pick 9 people from my friends list to confirm I “own” this blog. Among the ones I picked was Tommaso, the Quantum Diaries Survivor from next door. We got into a conversation about the question of blog ownership, a term that he seemed to find similarly bizarre as I do, and I thought it would be interesting to hear your opinion on that too.
Sure, I am writing this blog - well, most of it. But do I own it? One could equally well argue it is owned by Google. The only meaning of ownership that makes sense to me is that this blog is public property. Everybody who writes a blog knows what (s)he is doing when clicking on the “publish” button. It means your thoughts go out there, into the wild open.
Now don't get me wrong, of course I am pissed off if somebody uses my writings without paying credits to me. But if I write something where this aspect is of major importance I publish it such that I have a copyright on intellectual property. However, plagiarism doesn't seem to happen all that often even on blogs. For one, most people are actually honest and don't claim originally where there was none. Instead, over the years, we have had several requests to reprint articles or figures, to use quotations, and have been asked how to properly cite a blog post. But besides this, the very reason that blog posts are public provides safety through recognition of copies by readers. The more readers you have, the more likely one of them is to come across and recognize a plagiarism and notify you.
An effect much more interesting than actual copies and quotations however are follow-up threads were people continue a discussion that was initiated elsewhere. This pinging back and forth of thoughts through the blogosphere is as far as I am concerned one of the best aspects of it. What matters in the end however is the emergence of the discussion itself, not who owns it.
Sunday, December 14, 2008
What if... #14
What if all screws on this planet would suddenly dissolve?
This post is part of the 2008 advent series "What if..."
This post is part of the 2008 advent series "What if..."
Saturday, December 13, 2008
What if... #13
What if we would chose the members of parliament randomly from the whole population?
This post is part of the 2008 advent series "What if..."
This post is part of the 2008 advent series "What if..."
Friday, December 12, 2008
World's Friendliest Countries
1. Canada
2. Germany
3. Australia
4. UK
5. India
6. USA
7. Hong Kong
7. Spain
8. France
9. Netherlands
10. China
The study surveyed 2,155 expats in 48 countries, spanning four continents, between February and April 2008. Respondents rated their country in four categories: ability to befriend locals, number that joined a community group, number that learned the language and percentage that bought property. Source: Forbes.
2. Germany
3. Australia
4. UK
5. India
6. USA
7. Hong Kong
7. Spain
8. France
9. Netherlands
10. China
The study surveyed 2,155 expats in 48 countries, spanning four continents, between February and April 2008. Respondents rated their country in four categories: ability to befriend locals, number that joined a community group, number that learned the language and percentage that bought property. Source: Forbes.
What if... #12
What if we could see light over as large a frequency range as we can hear sound?
This post is part of the 2008 advent series "What if..."
This post is part of the 2008 advent series "What if..."
Thursday, December 11, 2008
Perimeter Scholars International
News from PI for our student readers:
Perimeter Scholars International (PSI) Provides New Opportunity for Young Researchers
Unique Masters Course Now Accepting Applications
Waterloo, Ontario, Canada, December 9, 2008 - Canada’s Perimeter Institute for Theoretical Physics (PI), in partnership with the University of Waterloo, has launched Perimeter Scholars International (PSI), a concentrated Masters level course for exceptional students who wish to become researchers in theoretical physics.
The 10-month course will be taught at the Perimeter Institute by outstanding international lecturers. Participants will be brought to the cutting edge of fundamental physics across a wide range of research disciplines, and conduct a specialized research project under the supervision of a faculty member at one of the local universities. The course will prepare students for PhD research in Theoretical Physics.
“Theoretical physics is the basis for much of modern science and technology. PSI is designed for adventurous students who wish to understand the deep principles underlying the physical world and how to translate them into observational predictions,” says Neil Turok, Perimeter Institute Director. “Our aim is to attract and nurture the brightest talents from across Canada and around the world and enable them to become brilliant young researchers contributing to future discoveries.”
The Masters degree will be issued by the University of Waterloo (UW), an internationally recognized university within walking distance of PI. UW President David Johnston says, “We are very pleased to join forces with Perimeter Institute and help propel this new model for research training. Such a program is long overdue. The ingenuity of PI and the academic foundation at UW will provide young researchers with unique opportunities to develop their skills.” Amit Chakma, UW Vice-President, Academic and Provost, adds, “PSI will see an influx of top talent into the existing research culture here in Waterloo, Ontario, while stimulating a new generation of scientists who can drive future discoveries of incalculable benefit to our world.”
PSI will enroll its first 25 students in August 2009, and will eventually grow to 50 scholars per year. Fully funded scholarships will be available as needed. Applications should be submitted by February 1st, 2009 in order to receive full consideration. For detailed information regarding all procedures, scholarship opportunities, supervision, accreditation, and program leadership, please visit the PSI website.
About Perimeter Institute
Canada's Perimeter Institute for Theoretical Physics is an independent, non-profit, scientific research and educational outreach organization where international scientists cluster to push the limits of our understanding of physical laws and develop new ideas about the very essence of space, time, matter and information. The award-winning research centre provides a multi-disciplinary environment to foster research in areas of Cosmology, Particle Physics, Quantum Foundations, Quantum Gravity, Quantum Information, Superstring Theory, and related areas. The Institute, located in Waterloo, Ontario, also provides a wide array of educational outreach activities for students, teachers and members of the general public in order to share the joy of scientific research, discovery and innovation. In partnership with the Governments of Ontario and Canada, Perimeter Institute continues to be a successful example of private and public collaboration in science research and education.
Contact Information
· PSI Program inquiries can be directed to John Berlinsky, PSI Director, at psi@perimeterinstitute.ca
· All other inquiries, such as media requests, should be directed to Angela Robinson at arobinson@perimeterinstitute.ca
Perimeter Scholars International (PSI) Provides New Opportunity for Young Researchers
Unique Masters Course Now Accepting Applications
Waterloo, Ontario, Canada, December 9, 2008 - Canada’s Perimeter Institute for Theoretical Physics (PI), in partnership with the University of Waterloo, has launched Perimeter Scholars International (PSI), a concentrated Masters level course for exceptional students who wish to become researchers in theoretical physics.
The 10-month course will be taught at the Perimeter Institute by outstanding international lecturers. Participants will be brought to the cutting edge of fundamental physics across a wide range of research disciplines, and conduct a specialized research project under the supervision of a faculty member at one of the local universities. The course will prepare students for PhD research in Theoretical Physics.
“Theoretical physics is the basis for much of modern science and technology. PSI is designed for adventurous students who wish to understand the deep principles underlying the physical world and how to translate them into observational predictions,” says Neil Turok, Perimeter Institute Director. “Our aim is to attract and nurture the brightest talents from across Canada and around the world and enable them to become brilliant young researchers contributing to future discoveries.”
The Masters degree will be issued by the University of Waterloo (UW), an internationally recognized university within walking distance of PI. UW President David Johnston says, “We are very pleased to join forces with Perimeter Institute and help propel this new model for research training. Such a program is long overdue. The ingenuity of PI and the academic foundation at UW will provide young researchers with unique opportunities to develop their skills.” Amit Chakma, UW Vice-President, Academic and Provost, adds, “PSI will see an influx of top talent into the existing research culture here in Waterloo, Ontario, while stimulating a new generation of scientists who can drive future discoveries of incalculable benefit to our world.”
PSI will enroll its first 25 students in August 2009, and will eventually grow to 50 scholars per year. Fully funded scholarships will be available as needed. Applications should be submitted by February 1st, 2009 in order to receive full consideration. For detailed information regarding all procedures, scholarship opportunities, supervision, accreditation, and program leadership, please visit the PSI website.
About Perimeter Institute
Canada's Perimeter Institute for Theoretical Physics is an independent, non-profit, scientific research and educational outreach organization where international scientists cluster to push the limits of our understanding of physical laws and develop new ideas about the very essence of space, time, matter and information. The award-winning research centre provides a multi-disciplinary environment to foster research in areas of Cosmology, Particle Physics, Quantum Foundations, Quantum Gravity, Quantum Information, Superstring Theory, and related areas. The Institute, located in Waterloo, Ontario, also provides a wide array of educational outreach activities for students, teachers and members of the general public in order to share the joy of scientific research, discovery and innovation. In partnership with the Governments of Ontario and Canada, Perimeter Institute continues to be a successful example of private and public collaboration in science research and education.
Contact Information
· PSI Program inquiries can be directed to John Berlinsky, PSI Director, at psi@perimeterinstitute.ca
· All other inquiries, such as media requests, should be directed to Angela Robinson at arobinson@perimeterinstitute.ca
Wednesday, December 10, 2008
What if... #10
What if water had a vanishingly small surface tension?
This post is part of the 2008 advent series "What if..."
This post is part of the 2008 advent series "What if..."
Tuesday, December 09, 2008
What if... #9
What if you could download a textbook directly on your brain?
This post is part of the 2008 advent series "What if..."
This post is part of the 2008 advent series "What if..."
Monday, December 08, 2008
Can Science Help Solve the Economic Crisis?
The Edge features a brilliant and timely essay
by Mike Brown, Stuart Kauffman, Zoe-Vonna Palmrose and Lee Smolin.
Having had the privilege to read a draft of this essay some weeks ago, I am thoroughly unsurprised to see my comments were completely ignored. To begin with, I must have repeated several times it is Jeffrey Sachs, Sachs, Sachs - not Sacks. Btw, his quotation used in section 4 you first read here. I doubt anybody else was stupid enough to rewind the recording two hundred times to do the transcript.
But that's what writing a blog is good for I guess, so I can now publish my comments here.
I largely agree with the overall scope of the essay, to the extend that my knowledge about economy is limited and some details escape me. The main statement however comes across very clearly: we need a scientific approach to modeling our economy, a necessity that have referred to as “Finishing the Scientific Revolution”. Given that our social, political, and economic systems affect the lives of billions of people this is in our responsibility as scientists. In their essay the authors make this point very aptly, pointing out especially the interdisciplinary nature of this endeavor:
The authors first summarize common assumptions of neoclassical economics and then proceed “to ask if there are alternative ideas, principles and methods of modeling economic systems which might also provide the basis for wise advice and policy.” My social democratic heart was very pleased to see they explicitly acknowledge the necessity to regulate a system so it can properly fulfill its function, and especially that it can do so without running into instabilities:
I previously wrote about the need to set up systems appropriately so they work towards their primary goal in my recent post The Best of All Possible Worlds.
Overall, the essay is for a bunch of Americans very well balanced and - in contrast to many other pamphlets on the topic that I have come across - notes that there is a plurality of what nations will consider optimal solutions depending on their citizens' preferences:
They finish with an appeal to scientists from different areas to join forces to increase our conceptual understanding of the systems that govern out lives with the aim to provide advice on their organization and regulation. Such an approach must be scientific, “should not be a matter of opinion or ideology” and “has to be carried out in an interdisciplinary and open spirit”. Or, as I put it in my post This is your Economy on Drugs
Indeed, one should fund an institute to carry out such research to extend the scientific method to the applications of social science. Doesn't that sound like a great idea? It certainly does to me! Though I am not exclusively concerned with the economic system, the more general goal of combining insights from the social, the natural and the computer sciences to better understand and manage the complex systems that shape our living together on this planet is the idea behind The Lightcone Institute (see also this post). If you happen not to have lost all your billions of dollars in the last months, I would greatly appreciate some start-up support.
Okay, before you throw up because I'm praising this essay too much, let me mention what I think the authors did not sufficiently emphasize. Throughout, the economic system is treated as being coupled to the political system only in the sense that the latter acts as a provider of regulations. The idea seems to be that scientists will gather, analyze and model the economy, and provide some advice for proper regulations.
That is a well meant, but very short-sighted attempt and bound to fail. You can't understand and update the economic system and improve its functioning without simultaneously understand and update the political system that is supposed to balance and regulate it. The cause of the problems we have is a severe mismatch in timescales on which the global economic system evolves and reacts, and the timescales on which our global political system evolves and reacts - the latter is lagging severely behind. To fix that problem the political system too needs a scientific investigation and advise on how to set up flexible institutions that are able to learn in a timely manner - instead of reacting with panic meetings only when things have already gone disastrously wrong.
Besides this, it might seem like a redundant point to mention, but the essay completely fails to at least address the central question what it actually is our economic system is supposed to work towards and who decides that - again the connection to the political system is missing. The primary purposes they mention (provide capital, provide a stable repository for our collective savings, provide credit to individuals) sounds perfectly reasonably, but are actually what I referred to not as primary, but secondary goals. I have no reason to question their desirability, but they are only relevant because of the benefit they bring in increasing the well-being of the people. That really should be the primary goal. And yes, scientists can help in achieving it.
by Mike Brown, Stuart Kauffman, Zoe-Vonna Palmrose and Lee Smolin.
Having had the privilege to read a draft of this essay some weeks ago, I am thoroughly unsurprised to see my comments were completely ignored. To begin with, I must have repeated several times it is Jeffrey Sachs, Sachs, Sachs - not Sacks. Btw, his quotation used in section 4 you first read here. I doubt anybody else was stupid enough to rewind the recording two hundred times to do the transcript.
But that's what writing a blog is good for I guess, so I can now publish my comments here.
I largely agree with the overall scope of the essay, to the extend that my knowledge about economy is limited and some details escape me. The main statement however comes across very clearly: we need a scientific approach to modeling our economy, a necessity that have referred to as “Finishing the Scientific Revolution”. Given that our social, political, and economic systems affect the lives of billions of people this is in our responsibility as scientists. In their essay the authors make this point very aptly, pointing out especially the interdisciplinary nature of this endeavor:
“When physicists made the atomic bomb they realized what they had conceived and immediately felt a sober responsibility to help make the world safe from their invention. At this time there is a responsibility for those with the knowledge and skills to understand the financial instruments involved in this crisis to help first to resolve this crisis and to next turn their attention to the design and regulation of a stable market system. This will involve economists, mathematicians, physicists, biologists, computer scientists and others working together to make a more stable economic system.”
The authors first summarize common assumptions of neoclassical economics and then proceed “to ask if there are alternative ideas, principles and methods of modeling economic systems which might also provide the basis for wise advice and policy.” My social democratic heart was very pleased to see they explicitly acknowledge the necessity to regulate a system so it can properly fulfill its function, and especially that it can do so without running into instabilities:
“[E]conomies, financial institutions and markets cannot function without a context of rules and laws, which regulate them. In a market, each participant tries to do the best they can for themselves. In a properly architected and regulated market this contributes to the public good. There is simply no place for an ideological discussion about regulation. Stable systems in nature such as individual organisms and ecosystems are regulated. So must ours be. The only relevant question is do the regulations work or not, where work means that stable markets allow an orderly flow of capital to and from the goods and services economy and the people who comprise it.”
I previously wrote about the need to set up systems appropriately so they work towards their primary goal in my recent post The Best of All Possible Worlds.
Overall, the essay is for a bunch of Americans very well balanced and - in contrast to many other pamphlets on the topic that I have come across - notes that there is a plurality of what nations will consider optimal solutions depending on their citizens' preferences:
“An economy involves finding balance between long- and short-term objectives, acceptable distributions of wealth, and rewards for innovation and risk taking. Different governments may embrace different social philosophies and may seek to establish economic and financial regulations to obtain somewhat different desired results. The role of an independent, non-partisan scientific conceptualization of economics should be to provide these policy makers with a notion as to the likelihood that new economic and financial regulations they are considering will have the results they desire and that these will not involve unintended consequences to others.”
They finish with an appeal to scientists from different areas to join forces to increase our conceptual understanding of the systems that govern out lives with the aim to provide advice on their organization and regulation. Such an approach must be scientific, “should not be a matter of opinion or ideology” and “has to be carried out in an interdisciplinary and open spirit”. Or, as I put it in my post This is your Economy on Drugs
“[T]he central issue is trust in our ability to detect and correct shortcomings of the system. A detection that should not be hindered by faith-based argumentation, should not be tampered with by rhetoric, should not be driven by psychological effects. It requires a solid data base, shared knowledge, objective evaluation, and validation of models and predictions. In short, it requires a scientific method to reestablish trust in the working of our political and economical systems.
The Scientific Revolution, which has lead to a stunning progress in the natural sciences four centuries ago, has not yet been extended to the applications of social sciences. To a large extend, developments in these areas are still made in a process of trial and error, experiments with the well-being of billions of people. It is a slow learning process often plagued by a lacking ability to learn from past mistakes. Given that trial and error has worked for a long time, and that the computational prerequisits to deal with large amounts of data are only available since recently, it is not surprising this revolution did not take place earlier. But it is about time we upgrade to the 21st Century.”
Indeed, one should fund an institute to carry out such research to extend the scientific method to the applications of social science. Doesn't that sound like a great idea? It certainly does to me! Though I am not exclusively concerned with the economic system, the more general goal of combining insights from the social, the natural and the computer sciences to better understand and manage the complex systems that shape our living together on this planet is the idea behind The Lightcone Institute (see also this post). If you happen not to have lost all your billions of dollars in the last months, I would greatly appreciate some start-up support.
Okay, before you throw up because I'm praising this essay too much, let me mention what I think the authors did not sufficiently emphasize. Throughout, the economic system is treated as being coupled to the political system only in the sense that the latter acts as a provider of regulations. The idea seems to be that scientists will gather, analyze and model the economy, and provide some advice for proper regulations.
That is a well meant, but very short-sighted attempt and bound to fail. You can't understand and update the economic system and improve its functioning without simultaneously understand and update the political system that is supposed to balance and regulate it. The cause of the problems we have is a severe mismatch in timescales on which the global economic system evolves and reacts, and the timescales on which our global political system evolves and reacts - the latter is lagging severely behind. To fix that problem the political system too needs a scientific investigation and advise on how to set up flexible institutions that are able to learn in a timely manner - instead of reacting with panic meetings only when things have already gone disastrously wrong.
Besides this, it might seem like a redundant point to mention, but the essay completely fails to at least address the central question what it actually is our economic system is supposed to work towards and who decides that - again the connection to the political system is missing. The primary purposes they mention (provide capital, provide a stable repository for our collective savings, provide credit to individuals) sounds perfectly reasonably, but are actually what I referred to not as primary, but secondary goals. I have no reason to question their desirability, but they are only relevant because of the benefit they bring in increasing the well-being of the people. That really should be the primary goal. And yes, scientists can help in achieving it.
Sunday, December 07, 2008
PS on "The Block Universe"
In May, I wrote a post on “The Block Universe,” a commentary on a paper by Vesselin Petkov that I thought might serve as a useful basis to explain why Special Relativity is not incompatible with presentism, the idea that it is only the “now” that “exists”. Note speech marks, for both are undefined terms. That lacking definition is essentially the point of my argument.
Now, some days ago, author of said paper contacted me to let me know I allegedly “completely failed to understand” what he wrote, and urged me to publish my writing in a journal so he could react to it, followed by “friendly warnings”. If I come around to converting my post appropriately, I might indeed send it somewhere, but it admittedly isn't very high on my list of priorities. As far as I am concerned, I said what I had to say, and the eternal reinterpretation of Special Relativity isn't a topic I am particularly keen on engaging in to begin with. It followed some back and forth of emails that did not amount to anything.
Such reminded that my statement might have confused some people, I thought it would be worthwhile to briefly summarize the point of my argument. It really isn't so hard to understand. Special Relativity is based on these axioms:
My argument is now simply, from these axioms you can not follow what “existence” means, thus you can not outrule presentism for it builds on this notion. You can then go ahead and produce a lot of fog by talking about clocks and rods and rulers and twins etc, but all of this is completely irrelevant. If you introduce additional assumptions about what constitutes a physical object then you might be able to come to conclusions. But these assumptions do not follow from Special Relativity and should be named explicitly.
As a concrete counter example for the claim that shows why this talk is empty, I suggested the following: Introduce an arbitrary time-like slicing in Minkowski-space and name it “existence slicing” to mean what is on the same slice “exists” together. This is not incompatible with Special Relativity.
No, there isn't anything more to this example, that was already it. I've shown one can define a notion of “existence” only on 3-dimensional submanifolds and this is compatible with Special Relativity. Now you can say you don't like this definition of “existence”. Fine. Nobody said you have to.
If you want you can understand “together” in the above example as “simultaneous”. This is not the notion of simultaneity commonly used in Special Relativity (based on inertial observers), but nobody forbids you to introduce a different one as you please. Again, you might not like that, but that was not a requirement I aimed to fulfill. For more precise statements, please see mentioned earlier post.
Just to make it clear, I personally don't even believe in presentism, I am just trying to say that the claim it is outruled through Special Relativity is logically false. If you want to come to any conclusions, you will need additional assumptions for what you mean with “existence”.
Now, some days ago, author of said paper contacted me to let me know I allegedly “completely failed to understand” what he wrote, and urged me to publish my writing in a journal so he could react to it, followed by “friendly warnings”. If I come around to converting my post appropriately, I might indeed send it somewhere, but it admittedly isn't very high on my list of priorities. As far as I am concerned, I said what I had to say, and the eternal reinterpretation of Special Relativity isn't a topic I am particularly keen on engaging in to begin with. It followed some back and forth of emails that did not amount to anything.
Such reminded that my statement might have confused some people, I thought it would be worthwhile to briefly summarize the point of my argument. It really isn't so hard to understand. Special Relativity is based on these axioms:
- Space and time form a 4-dimensional, flat, differentiable manifold with Lorentzian signature.
- The laws of physics are tensor equations over this manifold.
My argument is now simply, from these axioms you can not follow what “existence” means, thus you can not outrule presentism for it builds on this notion. You can then go ahead and produce a lot of fog by talking about clocks and rods and rulers and twins etc, but all of this is completely irrelevant. If you introduce additional assumptions about what constitutes a physical object then you might be able to come to conclusions. But these assumptions do not follow from Special Relativity and should be named explicitly.
As a concrete counter example for the claim that shows why this talk is empty, I suggested the following: Introduce an arbitrary time-like slicing in Minkowski-space and name it “existence slicing” to mean what is on the same slice “exists” together. This is not incompatible with Special Relativity.
No, there isn't anything more to this example, that was already it. I've shown one can define a notion of “existence” only on 3-dimensional submanifolds and this is compatible with Special Relativity. Now you can say you don't like this definition of “existence”. Fine. Nobody said you have to.
If you want you can understand “together” in the above example as “simultaneous”. This is not the notion of simultaneity commonly used in Special Relativity (based on inertial observers), but nobody forbids you to introduce a different one as you please. Again, you might not like that, but that was not a requirement I aimed to fulfill. For more precise statements, please see mentioned earlier post.
Just to make it clear, I personally don't even believe in presentism, I am just trying to say that the claim it is outruled through Special Relativity is logically false. If you want to come to any conclusions, you will need additional assumptions for what you mean with “existence”.
What if... #7
What if the Earth had two small moons instead of one?
This post is part of the 2008 advent series "What if..."
This post is part of the 2008 advent series "What if..."
Saturday, December 06, 2008
What if... #6
What if we could build a room in which time could be made to run faster or slower?
This post is part of the 2008 advent series "What if..."
This post is part of the 2008 advent series "What if..."
Friday, December 05, 2008
What if... #5
What if we found a way to predict the outcome of quantum measurements?
This post is part of the 2008 advent series "What if..."
This post is part of the 2008 advent series "What if..."
Thursday, December 04, 2008
What if... #4
What if we discovered a drug for immortality?
This post is part of the 2008 advent series "What if..."
This post is part of the 2008 advent series "What if..."
Wednesday, December 03, 2008
Tuesday, December 02, 2008
What if... #2
Today's thought experiment:
What if we could create anti-gravitating matter?
This post is part of the 2008 advent series "What if..."
What if we could create anti-gravitating matter?
This post is part of the 2008 advent series "What if..."
Monday, December 01, 2008
When Capitalism Fails
I guess some of you have been wondering why I occasionally put you through heavy reads like the recent “Best Of All Possible Worlds,” or my earlier elaboration on the reward system in “This is Your Economy on Drugs” instead of sticking with the fun and entertaining stuff, as one is supposed to do as a blogger?
Well, that's because now that you have patiently read all these lengthy explanations - and I am sure you have - I can finally draw the conclusions. See, if I say “love” before I've said “Money” “doesn't” and “buy,” you wouldn't get the message, would you?
Thus, I will now finally tell you why financing Open Access through author-pay is a bad idea, why science journalism is more Fiction than Fact, and will answer The Question Of All Questions: Who killed the blogosphere?
Yes. You will get answers to all this if you stay with me for a little while. It lies at hand now, and this hand isn't even invisible. Ready?
Okay! To summarize the most important points of my earlier writings: For a system to work towards its primary goal that system has to be endowed with a feedback mechanism. This mechanism has to allow for evaluation of the system's status, and needs to have enough flexibility to react to this evaluation, depending on whether a change works in favor or against achieving the primary goal. In social systems, feedback is most powerful if it arises from incentives on the personal level, meaning from criteria that are both local and immediate - in particular they have to be uncomplicated. The challenging task is to ensure that from these incentives on the micro-level there arises a trend that is desirable also on the long-term and long-distance scales.
Money, Money, Money

An example for such incentives that drive a system's behavior is operation for profit in our economical system. It works stunningly well and has resulted in such a remarkable optimization of our lives that many people have come to believe in its infallibility for guiding us towards happiness, and - with quite an impressive twist of thought - have equated its activity with progress itself. However, though the correlation between economic growth and increasing well-being of a nation's citizens might hold for a long range of GDP, this is a correlation and not an equality. It's like your children's growth tells about their health, but what you really want is them to be healthy, and not continue growing eternally. This is what I refer to as the confusion of primary goals (here: health, happiness) with secondary criteria (here: growth/economic growth).
Besides this, it is also well known that operation for profit alone does not take into account many long-term and long-distance effects that a society might strive for. This is typically the cases when a development will not be initialized through individual action, either because the individual would put himself in a disadvantage by taking the action, or because she would put herself into an advantage when she was the only one not taking the action (also known as a "free ride").
Examples might be costly expenses for environmental protection (putting the company in a
disadvantage with competitors who don't have these expenses), or everybody spending a tenner, so somebody can fix all these potholes (advantage of profiting from the improved pavement nevertheless if enough other people spends some bucks). This is also known as the collective action problem.
These goals are thus often achieved by changing the incentive structure through fees, taxes or simply legal restrictions. The point of balancing the economical system with a political one is that the latter gives us a way to include the pursuit of goals that would fail when only looked at from the individual point of view.
Must be funny
Money however is not the only immediate and local feedback that drives our societies. For a different kind of feedback, take the blogosphere. Here, the currency is attention. You trade it through links and comments, and count it in visits per day. Another sort of feedback are reviews at Amazon, PageRank or more generally every kind of rating. In many cases, these feedback cycles are related to money, but a priori they are goals by themselves.
However, we all have to live from something, and that something still has to be paid. Thus, whatever service it is you are asking for, somebody has to pay for it. The internet offers an astonishing amount of information - and it's free! Or is it? Well, the price you pay is that the web has gotten swamped with advertisements, because that's the only readily available way to get the money in (unless you belong to the lucky few that can survive on donations).
That wouldn't have to be the case, but currently that is where the incentives are. The more visitors you attract, the more you get in with ads, meaning the only criterion is how much people like what you put on the web. This is a feedback. It is immediate, and it results in a learning curve. This feedback however leads quite obviously towards populism. If that is your primary goal, then it works. Everything else... will be struggling.
In a rich man's world
Now, why do we see so much bad science journalism and so many over-hyped sensational stories? Because there is insufficient feedback that rewards quality. Quality is just simply not a criterion that is optimized for, and increasingly less so the more funding needs to come from advertisements and via high Google ranking. Here is an extract from an email that I received from a popular science magazine after I remarked some of their advertisements are of scientifically doubtful content:
Not that this came as a surprise to me, still, it is somehow depressing to have it stated that clearly. There is a tension in this arrangement between the goal of the advertiser and that of the publisher. It takes effort to keep up a tension, and the tendency is towards an equilibrium where advertisements match the reader's interests, for example by dumbing the reader down.
The open access movement has a similar financing problem which is that giving free access to publications doesn't pay off. There is no source for funding of necessary staff and editors. Thus, the money has to come from elsewhere than from the readers.
The most widely used model is that the author pays a charge. Though I am all in favor of open access, this option is a huge mistake if you consider what it means for science in the long run: With traditional publishing you couldn't read a paper if you couldn't afford it. With author-pay you can't publish a paper if you can't afford it. What does the incentive structure look like then? Well, the news is that journals will be interested in having good contacts to affiliations that do financially well. Does that sound like a bias you want to have on the scientific publishing process? Just asking.
The other option is to be financed through advertisements, which suffers from the same problem as journalism that I mentioned above. The incentives don't go towards quality, but towards populism. That also isn't something I want to affect scientific publishing.
There is an obvious solution to the problem. If I mention this in the presence of Americans they stare at me in disbelieve, but it seems to me a logical conclusion from what I've told you above: Open access is a public service. Thus, it should be financed like a public service. That does not necessarily mean neither it needs to be governmentally funded, nor through taxation. There are other options.
One that I discussed with Stefan a while ago is to simply use the existing library committees with a funding that possibly could be much smaller than in the traditional system. Instead of buying subscriptions however, let them rate journals according to criteria of quality and importance and distribute grants according to this. It's a flexible system of evaluation and feedback and has at least a chance to work towards quality.
But really, who killed the blogosphere?
If you read Nicholas Carr's post (and don't miss the postscriptum), you will find that he is not so much bemoaning the death of the blogosphere, but more its commercialization:
So who killed the blogosphere? Well, we killed it by omission. It's our choice to set up the systems we operate in such that they work towards what we want. Capitalism isn't the only choice, and its invisible hand is not infallible.
Bottomline

Where is the love? It's in your hands. And these hands aren't even invisible.
Well, that's because now that you have patiently read all these lengthy explanations - and I am sure you have - I can finally draw the conclusions. See, if I say “love” before I've said “Money” “doesn't” and “buy,” you wouldn't get the message, would you?
Thus, I will now finally tell you why financing Open Access through author-pay is a bad idea, why science journalism is more Fiction than Fact, and will answer The Question Of All Questions: Who killed the blogosphere?
Yes. You will get answers to all this if you stay with me for a little while. It lies at hand now, and this hand isn't even invisible. Ready?
Okay! To summarize the most important points of my earlier writings: For a system to work towards its primary goal that system has to be endowed with a feedback mechanism. This mechanism has to allow for evaluation of the system's status, and needs to have enough flexibility to react to this evaluation, depending on whether a change works in favor or against achieving the primary goal. In social systems, feedback is most powerful if it arises from incentives on the personal level, meaning from criteria that are both local and immediate - in particular they have to be uncomplicated. The challenging task is to ensure that from these incentives on the micro-level there arises a trend that is desirable also on the long-term and long-distance scales.
Money, Money, Money

An example for such incentives that drive a system's behavior is operation for profit in our economical system. It works stunningly well and has resulted in such a remarkable optimization of our lives that many people have come to believe in its infallibility for guiding us towards happiness, and - with quite an impressive twist of thought - have equated its activity with progress itself. However, though the correlation between economic growth and increasing well-being of a nation's citizens might hold for a long range of GDP, this is a correlation and not an equality. It's like your children's growth tells about their health, but what you really want is them to be healthy, and not continue growing eternally. This is what I refer to as the confusion of primary goals (here: health, happiness) with secondary criteria (here: growth/economic growth).
Besides this, it is also well known that operation for profit alone does not take into account many long-term and long-distance effects that a society might strive for. This is typically the cases when a development will not be initialized through individual action, either because the individual would put himself in a disadvantage by taking the action, or because she would put herself into an advantage when she was the only one not taking the action (also known as a "free ride").
Examples might be costly expenses for environmental protection (putting the company in a
disadvantage with competitors who don't have these expenses), or everybody spending a tenner, so somebody can fix all these potholes (advantage of profiting from the improved pavement nevertheless if enough other people spends some bucks). This is also known as the collective action problem.These goals are thus often achieved by changing the incentive structure through fees, taxes or simply legal restrictions. The point of balancing the economical system with a political one is that the latter gives us a way to include the pursuit of goals that would fail when only looked at from the individual point of view.
Must be funny
Money however is not the only immediate and local feedback that drives our societies. For a different kind of feedback, take the blogosphere. Here, the currency is attention. You trade it through links and comments, and count it in visits per day. Another sort of feedback are reviews at Amazon, PageRank or more generally every kind of rating. In many cases, these feedback cycles are related to money, but a priori they are goals by themselves.
However, we all have to live from something, and that something still has to be paid. Thus, whatever service it is you are asking for, somebody has to pay for it. The internet offers an astonishing amount of information - and it's free! Or is it? Well, the price you pay is that the web has gotten swamped with advertisements, because that's the only readily available way to get the money in (unless you belong to the lucky few that can survive on donations).
That wouldn't have to be the case, but currently that is where the incentives are. The more visitors you attract, the more you get in with ads, meaning the only criterion is how much people like what you put on the web. This is a feedback. It is immediate, and it results in a learning curve. This feedback however leads quite obviously towards populism. If that is your primary goal, then it works. Everything else... will be struggling.
In a rich man's world
Now, why do we see so much bad science journalism and so many over-hyped sensational stories? Because there is insufficient feedback that rewards quality. Quality is just simply not a criterion that is optimized for, and increasingly less so the more funding needs to come from advertisements and via high Google ranking. Here is an extract from an email that I received from a popular science magazine after I remarked some of their advertisements are of scientifically doubtful content:
“[R]emember that ads pay for the content, paper and mailing of magazines. I trust that our readership is bright enough to appreciate the fine work of Scientists and the value of Science to their world and can sift through and filter out advertising that they don't believe is of value [...] It's important to remember that advertising pays for the value of most of a magazine. Subscribers actually only cover a small part of the cost of any magazine.”
Not that this came as a surprise to me, still, it is somehow depressing to have it stated that clearly. There is a tension in this arrangement between the goal of the advertiser and that of the publisher. It takes effort to keep up a tension, and the tendency is towards an equilibrium where advertisements match the reader's interests, for example by dumbing the reader down.
The open access movement has a similar financing problem which is that giving free access to publications doesn't pay off. There is no source for funding of necessary staff and editors. Thus, the money has to come from elsewhere than from the readers.
The most widely used model is that the author pays a charge. Though I am all in favor of open access, this option is a huge mistake if you consider what it means for science in the long run: With traditional publishing you couldn't read a paper if you couldn't afford it. With author-pay you can't publish a paper if you can't afford it. What does the incentive structure look like then? Well, the news is that journals will be interested in having good contacts to affiliations that do financially well. Does that sound like a bias you want to have on the scientific publishing process? Just asking.
The other option is to be financed through advertisements, which suffers from the same problem as journalism that I mentioned above. The incentives don't go towards quality, but towards populism. That also isn't something I want to affect scientific publishing.
There is an obvious solution to the problem. If I mention this in the presence of Americans they stare at me in disbelieve, but it seems to me a logical conclusion from what I've told you above: Open access is a public service. Thus, it should be financed like a public service. That does not necessarily mean neither it needs to be governmentally funded, nor through taxation. There are other options.
One that I discussed with Stefan a while ago is to simply use the existing library committees with a funding that possibly could be much smaller than in the traditional system. Instead of buying subscriptions however, let them rate journals according to criteria of quality and importance and distribute grants according to this. It's a flexible system of evaluation and feedback and has at least a chance to work towards quality.
But really, who killed the blogosphere?
If you read Nicholas Carr's post (and don't miss the postscriptum), you will find that he is not so much bemoaning the death of the blogosphere, but more its commercialization:
“That vast, free-wheeling, and surprisingly intimate forum where individual writers shared their observations, thoughts, and arguments outside the bounds of the traditional media is gone. Almost all of the popular blogs today are commercial ventures with teams of writers, aggressive ad-sales operations, bloated sites, and strategies of self-linking.”And is anybody really surprised by that? As he aptly remarks later “For the lion's share of bloggers, the rewards just aren't worth the effort.” The question is now once again what does the present system with its feedback driven by popularity optimize? Individuality? Hardly.
So who killed the blogosphere? Well, we killed it by omission. It's our choice to set up the systems we operate in such that they work towards what we want. Capitalism isn't the only choice, and its invisible hand is not infallible.
- “What will we do?
What will we say?
When it's the end of this game that we play?
Will we crumble into the dust my friend?
Or will we start this game over again?”
Bottomline

Where is the love? It's in your hands. And these hands aren't even invisible.
What if...
![]() | We've been wondering what to do this year at advent time. Last year's “Plottl a Day” was great fun, but this year unfortunately neither Stefan nor I have much time. Thus, we thought this year we'd make it an interactive advent season and count on you to make it memorable! |
We will suggest a one-line science fiction scenario every day, and hope you let your fantasy go wild :-)
Here is the first:
What if we could change the value of Planck's constant?
Also... we haven't yet quite 24 “What if's” together. So, if you have a scenario that you'd love to speculate about, leave it in the comments!
- #2: What if we could create anti-gravitating matter?
- #3: What if carbon dioxide was pink?
- #4: What if we discovered a drug for immortality?
- #5: What if we found a way to predict the outcome of quantum measurements?
- #6: What if we could build a room in which time could be made to run faster or slower?
- #7: What if the Earth had two small moons instead of one?
- #8: What if all the world leaders were women?
- #9: What if you could download a textbook directly on your brain?
- #10: What if water had a vanishingly small surface tension?
- #11: What if we could grow hardware on trees?
- #12: What if we could see light over as large a frequency range as we can hear sound?
- #13: What if we would chose the members of parliament randomly from the whole population?
- #14: What if all screws on this planet would suddenly dissolve?
- #15: What if the Sun was hotter and more blue, or cooler and more red than it is?
- #16: What if our vacuum was only metastable and started decaying tomorrow morning?
- #17: What if somebody we've never heard of found a way to compute all the ratios of masses in the standard model (without introducing new ad hoc parameters)?
- #18: What if the left and the right side of the human brain were considerably better connected?
- #19: What if the memory of all electronic data storage media was suddenly erased?
- #20: What if we could arbitrarily rescale the size of all objects?
- #21: What if all Curie temperatures drop to zero and matter loses permanent magnetisation?
- #22: What if the internet became self-aware?
- #23: What if SETI detects strange radio signals from a star with an exoplanet?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
